Home of the Squeezebox™ & Transporter® network music players.
Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 21
  1. #1

    What is an "Album" for Squeezecenter

    I've been assuming that logically it would be all tracks sharing the album title and album artist fields and not location. That hasn't proved to be true with albums split across folders for me. The album appears as as many albums as the artists (folders) involved. Same thing happens to box sets by a single artist if they are subdivided into a folder each for each CD.

    Have tried Mediamonkey and Tag & Rename for retagging these files alongwith all possible combos in Squeezecenter settings for various artists (bands)with full rescans (not update scans) to no avail.

    My music is organized by Genre\Artist\Year_Album\Track No_Title with a Folder.jpg in each location. Compilations thus end up split by artist. I find this helpful for various reasons and would like to keep it that way. But while a file is playing, I'd like to keep the flexibility of either navigating to other albums by the same artist or other artists on the same album using the Squeezebox controller. Its also annoying to see multiple entries for a single box set by a single artist.
    I'm sure someone has this working right. Would appreciate learning the secret.
    Last edited by guptaas; 2008-11-13 at 22:08. Reason: Broken English

  2. #2
    Senior Member aubuti's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    8,832
    For box sets, make sure that all tracks have the exact same album tag (i.e., don't include "(disc 1)" in the album name), and fill the DISCNUMBER tag with the correct disc number and they should display and play as one album.

    For compilations, the tracks have to be in the same folder. You would still have the flexibility of following other tracks on the album, or other tracks by the artist (by drilling down into track info, and then following the artist branch). But it would mean re-organizing your folder structure.

    A good tagging program like mp3tag can help you make these changes.
    Audio system in transition while still relocating from halfway around the world.
    Man-cave: SB3 > Emotiva XDA-1 > NAD C 325BEE > Vandersteen 1
    Living room: SB2 > Audioengine HD6
    Kitchen/dining: SB2 > AudioSource AMP 100 > 2-pairs of Polk Audio RC60i in-ceiling speakers
    Deck/patio: SB Receiver > AudioSource AMP 100 > Polk Atrium 45
    Study: SB Radio
    LMS 8.0 running on a Raspberry Pi3 (max2play), controlled using SB Controller, iPeng and Squeezepad

  3. #3
    Sorry to belabor the point, but I'm trying to approach this from the very definition of what is an "album"

    Your description suggests that that an album is a set of all tracks sharing artist & album fields, irrespective of track location when artist=album-artist. But when artist field has multiple values then an album is a set of tracks from a single folder sharing the album and album-artist fields. You could be right and that may be how the software is set-up but it does seem odd why it was done that way.

    Then we still get stumped by box sets of compilations which need to be broken into folders by CD.

    The tagging software I've used so far is fairly standard amongst enthusiasts though I do plan to try MP3Tag. I always tag files in groups so that typos or inadvertent space characters cannot create duplicates. Disc numbers are where they belong, not in the album name. The error has to be in my settings of Squeezecenter, my understanding of how it operates or a "clean" rescan not willing to "forget" info from previous scans.

  4. #4
    Senior Member aubuti's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    8,832
    Quote Originally Posted by guptaas View Post
    Sorry to belabor the point, but I'm trying to approach this from the very definition of what is an "album"

    Your description suggests that that an album is a set of all tracks sharing artist & album fields, irrespective of track location when artist=album-artist. But when artist field has multiple values then an album is a set of tracks from a single folder sharing the album and album-artist fields. You could be right and that may be how the software is set-up but it does seem odd why it was done that way.
    From my POV, an album is what you buy when you buy a CD or LP. It's a collection of tracks on one or more discs, put together by artist(s) and and/or recording execs who thinks that for some reason they belong together. I said the tracks had to have the same album tag, but never said anything about the artist tag. Obviously there are thousands of compilation albums with multiple artists and no readily identifiable "albumartist".

    Album names are non-unique, even in a given year ("Greatest Hits" being only the most extreme example). SC needs to have some way to know which tracks on a multi-artist compilation go together, and which ones don't. Putting tracks from the same album in the same folder accomplishes this. Your folder structure is logical, but so is /artist/album/track (for single-artist albums) and /Various Artists/album/track (for multi-artist albums). That's how SC is set up. If you do it this way you can still have *all* tracks by an artist listed even though some are in the /Various Artists/ branch.

    Quote Originally Posted by guptaas View Post
    Then we still get stumped by box sets of compilations which need to be broken into folders by CD.
    No, they don't. You can put them into different folders, or you can put them all in one folder. If you do the latter then you might want to renumber the tracks so they are one series: 1, 2, ..., n, but you don't have to.

    Quote Originally Posted by guptaas View Post
    The tagging software I've used so far is fairly standard amongst enthusiasts though I do plan to try MP3Tag. I always tag files in groups so that typos or inadvertent space characters cannot create duplicates. Disc numbers are where they belong, not in the album name. The error has to be in my settings of Squeezecenter, my understanding of how it operates or a "clean" rescan not willing to "forget" info from previous scans.
    I don't have SC in front of me right now, but check the settings for "Treat multi-disc albums as a single set" and the settings for Various Artists. I think they're both on the Music Library tab in Settings.
    Audio system in transition while still relocating from halfway around the world.
    Man-cave: SB3 > Emotiva XDA-1 > NAD C 325BEE > Vandersteen 1
    Living room: SB2 > Audioengine HD6
    Kitchen/dining: SB2 > AudioSource AMP 100 > 2-pairs of Polk Audio RC60i in-ceiling speakers
    Deck/patio: SB Receiver > AudioSource AMP 100 > Polk Atrium 45
    Study: SB Radio
    LMS 8.0 running on a Raspberry Pi3 (max2play), controlled using SB Controller, iPeng and Squeezepad

  5. #5
    Senior Member JJZolx's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    Colorado
    Posts
    11,547
    To SqueezeCenter, location (folder/directory) is significant. I think this was a change made to 6.0 or 6.5 to simplify the logic for differentiating between albums with the same name. This has caused some issues for people who'd rather organize their music by artist or some other system, rather than strictly one-album-per-folder.

  6. #6
    Quote Originally Posted by JJZolx View Post
    To SqueezeCenter, location (folder/directory) is significant. I think this was a change made to 6.0 or 6.5 to simplify the logic for differentiating between albums with the same name. This has caused some issues for people who'd rather organize their music by artist or some other system, rather than strictly one-album-per-folder.
    Thank you for answering my question. I was mistaken in thinking that tags were the only tool used to build the database. A "Various Artist" folder under genre will take care of it.

  7. #7
    MrSinatra
    Guest
    album is just a database characteristic, its not a unique identifier.

    its not totally clear what all SC does, but it does use location, folder names, tag info, etc... and sometimes some "logics" of its own that aren't defined.

    its an interesting question tho u pose... b/c i remember when an "album" consisted of two distinct parts... a side A and a side B. that concept seems to have all but died, but a lot of great albums were conceived of as such. dark side of the moon, sgt pepper, abbey road, who's next, etc... its really an endless list; albums were meant to be digested and the story they told in "sides" that together were the album.

    i miss that concept, and would like to see "side a" and "side b" tag come into play in the CDDBs of the world.

    aside from the "sides" issue, i'd say an album can loosely technically be defined as any group of tracks appearing on one CD or LP. however, a lot of people think of albums in the tighter context of a grouping of original songs, whereas 'compilation albums' is a subset where you have a greatest hits or various artists grouping of songs.

    don't trust SC to give you reliable stats for things either, it contradicts itself all over the place and i have a bug in for that. i use winamp which i trust a lot more for stats.

  8. #8
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Posts
    5

    Angry

    I have a lot of classical box sets and this behaviour where squeezecenter treats albums as different when the tracks are spread across separate folders is really very irritating. Surely it should only look at the tags, not the folder structure?

    Is there any way at all to overcome this other than physically moving files in to the same folders?

  9. #9
    Senior Member Siduhe's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    deepest, darkest, south-east London
    Posts
    3,238
    Try adding a Compilation=1 (or yes) tag to the affected files. Then do a clear and rescan.
    Who am I on LAST.FM?
    "Siduhe Loved Tracks radio got the thumbs up. Feedback included: yeah, it's good... got the odd dodgy track tho..." (c) ModelCitizen

  10. #10
    Senior Member Moonbase's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    Krumbach, Germany
    Posts
    750
    You might want to vote for bug 10583 which cured all these "different folder, same album" problems for me.

    Maybe, just maybe, we have a little chance that this will be retrofitted into 7.3.3/7.4 instead of being postponed forever.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •