PDA

View Full Version : Best Hard Drive Format...Switched From PC To Mac



Jayrcee
2012-02-19, 18:10
I just switched from a PC to a Mac and am in the process of moving all of my systems files over to my Mac's internal hard drive (presently formated in the default Mac OS Extended (Journaled)). I would like to stay within the Mac "ecosystem" from here on out. I would like to to know what file system I should use for my new WD 2tb external hard drive that I plan on copying my music collection over to? It's doubtful I will be working in a Windows environment anymore. I need it to be compatible with Logitech Media Server and my Squeezebox Boom. On my PC I had my music scattered over 3 NTFS formatted internal hard drives and I want to consolidate it all on the new 2tb external.
Thanks in advance!

gharris999
2012-02-19, 18:41
I just switched from a PC to a Mac and am in the process of moving all of my systems files over to my Mac's internal hard drive (presently formated in the default Mac OS Extended (Journaled)). I would like to stay within the Mac "ecosystem" from here on out. I would like to to know what file format I should use for my new WD 2tb external hard drive that I plan on copying my music collection over to? It's doubtful I will be working in a Windows environment anymore. I need it to be compatible with Logitech Media Server and my Squeezebox Boom. On my PC I had my music scatteredy over 3 NTFS formatted internal hard drives and I want to consolidate it all on the new 2tb external.
Thanks in advance!
FLAC is still best for Squeezeboxes, no matter what OS is on the server. As far as I can tell the support for FLAC in the Mac ecosystem is more limited than it is in Windows. I wouldn't be surprised if die hard Mac fanbois advise you to go with alec...Apple's proprietary lossless format. At least Apple has released encoder and decoder source code now. But that format is far from being anything that can be considered open source. Anyway, the only objection that's likely to be raised about alec is the fact that the squeezebox supports that format only via server side transcoding. If you're ok with that, then go with alec.

Jayrcee
2012-02-19, 18:43
Thanks for the response!
My music is already in FLAC format. I need to know what file system format the hard drive should be formatted to :)

gharris999
2012-02-19, 18:45
Rereading your post, I'm wondering if you're asking about disc file system rather than audio file format. If that's the case, go with Mac Extended. If this disc will hold mostly just your audio library, you can probably do without the journaling.

Jeff Flowerday
2012-02-19, 18:53
exFat that way it works on Window and Mac.

Nikhil
2012-02-19, 23:53
There's quite a lot of options for Mac users:

1) The default HFS+(J) is probably the simplest. If you are working in an all Mac environment, this should be fine. If you need cross platform support, most linux distros allow you to access this as read only and you can download a free read/write linux HFS+ driver from Paragon (http://www.paragon-software.com/home/ntfs-linux-per/). For Windows access to HFS+ drives you can use the MacDrive commercial drivers from MediaFour (http://www.mediafour.com/products/macdrive) or Paragon (http://www.paragon-software.com/home/hfs-windows/).

2) Plain old FAT32 is aging but will work out of the box with almost any OS including directly with a SqueezeBox Touch. The main limitation is the 4GB individual file size, which might be a problem if you intend to store video files on the same drive as well, but for audio files only, it should not be a problem.

3) You can stick with NTFS and use either a free open source Mac read write driver like NTFS-3G (http://www.tuxera.com/community/ntfs-3g-download/) or commercial versions from Tuxera (http://www.tuxera.com/products/tuxera-ntfs-for-mac/) or Paragon (http://www.paragon-software.com/home/ntfs-mac/). NTFS has relatively robust cross platform support either out of the box or through open source drivers, including native access by the SqueezeBox touch.

4) As stated above exFAT from Microsoft is another option. It is similar to FAT32 but removes the 4GB file size restriction. It supported by most recent releases of Windows (I think Win 7 and above, but can be added to XP and Vista as a free download) and MacOS (I think OS 10.6 and above). There is also a FUSE read/write driver for linux (http://code.google.com/p/exfat/), and because this format is the official format for SDXC flash cards, we are likely to see a lot more support in the future.

5) Finally if you would like to protect your data well, you might want to consider ZFS. A commercial mac version from Ten's Complement (http://tenscomplement.com/) called Zevo Silver Edition (http://tenscomplement.com/our-products/zevo-silver-edition) recently became available and there's also an open source version (http://code.google.com/p/maczfs/).

Jayrcee
2012-02-20, 14:34
Thanks everyone for the suggestions! After a little research, HFS+ seems the most practical for me, however ZFS has me intrigued :) I forgot to mention that in the near future, I plan on ripping my Blu-ray collection to hard drives as well. They would be placed together with the new music drive in an Atom based media server of sorts.

Eric Seaberg
2012-02-22, 22:24
Keep it HFS+. Keeping everything as FLAC, you won't have a native Mac app that can see them, except for Max. http://sbooth.org/Max/ It's a GREAT APP that can rip, convert, tag, etc., any file type you may encounter on the Mac. I use it to rip all CDs to FLAC, then transcode to AAC so iTunes can import them to my iPhone.

Please feel free to email me offline if you need some help. DON'T BE AFRAID of MAC OS. It's very simple and intuitive once you've gotten past the Windows way of looking at things.

brillo
2012-02-22, 22:37
Another vote for HFS+ (which is the same thing as Mac OS Extended)...