View Full Version : Better forum please!

2005-04-05, 05:43
Wrong? It's my opinion versus yours. Neither one of us is right
or wrong.

I deal with an extremely large volume of mail every day. On
the order of 300 messages alone for work. I don't use forums because
they require me to visit them. The comparison between e-mail vs.
forum is like going to a buffet where all my food is vs. having to go
to a restaurant for some take out food. I am an active participant
in this list plus two other high volume lists. As much as I'd like to

use a forum for some of my other interests, I can't for the following

1. I can't. My company prohibits access to forums.
2. I won't. I takes too much time for me to browse through
every topic. I like to be very familiar with something. With forums
I might miss some discussion because the subject is incorrect.
3. It's inefficient for me. I downloaded all my mail last night
to my I pod before I left work. Listened to most of it via a TTS
engine in my car on the way home and I am responding to you offline.
When I get into work, this e-mail will be uploaded and sent on it's
merry way.

I can easily listen to about 200 messages on the way home, especially
when I've got the acceleration turned to 1.5 or even 2x normal.

Just because e-mail has been around since the 70's doesn't mean a forum

is progress. If 60% of users don't participate, that's fine. This
is not for the normal user, it's for techies. If there is so much
desire for a forum, one of the users would have created it or
a wiki. I haven't seen either. And the wiki that slim devices has
is not updated, most likely because people don't really have the
desire to do so.

It has already been stated that most of the developers now will
not go to a forum. Slim devices is an open source company
at the heart of their business, so please explain to me why they
would use something like vbulletin? Also, how can I use a forum
during the day, while at work, when such things are prevented.

My employer has no issue with me participating on this list, and
I am very productive at work, so it's not like I goof off all day.
I just am very lucky to sit at a computer writing programs all
day, so taking a break every hour or so to check out what's in
my inbox is no big deal. Especially when my coworkers spend
double that amount of time taking smoke breaks.

It's not like I don't understand forums. I just hate the fact that
forums take so much bandwidth. Each page visit requires clicks,
navigation, etc. and every forum has a slightly different
interface. With e-mail, every list I'm on has the same interface,
plus I don't have to go visit and browse around when I want
to catch up with what the latest information posted is. I know...
I run an internal forum for my company. So don't tell me
I'm wrong. You can tell me you don't have the same feeling.

However, I can tell you that currently, there is no way to download
all new posts in a forum and have it make sense in a TTS engine.
That in itself would kill any efficiency I make up for on the way home

or the way back into work. Slim devices doesn't need forums, it
needs a more stable server. I'd rather they devote time to getting
it running well, rather than have a really cool forum, only so that
users can post more information about how their slimserver is
crashing every day.

Oh, yeah, one other thing. Thanks for insulting me by telling
me what advantages I do or don't see with this format vs.
others. If you like forums so much, go create one yourself
and invite people from this list to it. phpBB is a very good
OS one to consider.


>>> mixerboy (AT) hotmail (DOT) com 04/05/05 5:41 AM >>>
Hi Paul

I am sorry but you are wrong. This system is the kinda thing that was
running in the late 60's/70's - things have come a long way since then.
devices have an excellent product that is going to grow and support
allow other uses to share their experience leaving the staff to spend
time developing the products we all enjoy.
I would expect 60% of new users will not participate with this current

mailing list because it is ugly, slow and not straight forward which is
all major websites offering support, do not use mailing list support
and have easy to use/navigate web based forums.

If you cannot see the lucidly clear advantaged of using a system like
vbulitin then you are clearly beyond any ability to form an intelligent

opinion. Please research what a modern forum system like vbulitin is
of. You mention it is possible to view the current posts in a forum
interface already. Well if that is your idea of a forum interface no
you are against it - the current system is dire.
I am not say this mailing list should cease, just a new system be put
I want to see slim devices grow and this support forum issue must be
with sooner or later.



----Original Message Follows----
From: "PAUL WILLIAMSON" <pwilliamson (AT) mandtbank (DOT) com>
To: mixerboy (AT) hotmail (DOT) com
Subject: [slim] Better forum please!
Date: Sun, 03 Apr 2005 20:28:06 -0400

Look in the archives. Forums for a lot of people suck. With e-mail,
I can participate in many more projects and only have to
deal with one interface.

Good luck, but if you put 1% of effort into looking in the
archives (which are ina forum format already), you'll see
this gets brought up every once in a while and slim devices
is in the process of addressing it in their own FOSS way.


>>> mixerboy (AT) hotmail (DOT) com 04/03/05 7:08 PM >>>
Please please can we have a better support forum? This type of mailing
list forum belongs in the dark ages and makes support and
slow and tiring.

Something like www.vbulletin.com is the way to go. SD needs to make
support as stunning as its devices.
Hope you folks agree.