PDA

View Full Version : Tagging Issue



amey01
2017-11-19, 05:06
I fail to believe I can't find anything on this issue by searching, but maybe I'm just searching the wrong thing?

I have an issue, which stems from one particular Windows computer running MP3Tag. Any file tagged with this system is problematic with LMS. It is:

Read by any other music player
Shows up in the LMS library
Does not show when added to a playlist (now playing playlist, or any other playlist)
The file plays at the appropriate place in the playlist (notwithstanding it not displaying)
The file plays with no issue
When the file is playing, it does not show any tag data on the SBT. On iPeng, it displays the previous track data.

What error or setting could be causing this?

karlek
2017-11-19, 05:22
What types an version of Tag is this mp3tag using?
I followed an advice to only write id3v2 tags and remove all others.

iPhone
2017-11-19, 08:52
.
Helpful Reading from the Slim Devices Wiki: http://wiki.slimdevices.com/index.php/Beginners_Guide_To_Tagging

"MP3 files store tag information ("metadata", or data about data) in "ID3" tags. See Wikipedia for a discussion on the differences between ID3v1 (old!) and ID3v2 (newer!). Note both types can be present in a file simultaneously.
With SqueezeCenter, it would be best to eliminate ID3v1 tags entirely, skip ID3v2.2 and use ID3v2.3 or ID3v2.4 alone. ID3v1 tags are limited to 30 characters. Your tagging program of choice may correctly display truncated titles, but it may instead display ID3v2 tag titles or even data from its own cache, and it may not let you know what it's displaying. SqueezeCenter attempts to use ID3v2 if both tag types are present, but with so many different tag types, you can get confused as to which ones your files have. If you have incorrect tag data that seems to persist after you correct it and rescan, look for ID3v1 tags and eliminate them.
Note that some portable devices do not support ID3v2.4 tags yet.
APEv2 tags can also be present in an MP3 along with the ID3 tag types, this further confuses matters. Only MP3Gain should write APEv2 tags - do not put text-based data in APEv2 tags.
FLAC and OGG files store tags in VORBIS comments. (Be careful, as FLAC files can contain VORBIS comments and ID3 tags at the same time. If at all possible delete all ID3 tags from the flac file. FLAC standard only guarantees that VORBIS comments will be read by any flac compliant program, while ID3 may be read by some but not by others.This has confused some people, who were modifying the ID3 tags instead of the VORBIS ones, and not seeing the proper result.)
APE tags are similar to VORBIS comments, in that they are free-form. They are the native tag format for Musepack & Monkey's Audio formats. Additionally, APE tags are often used to store ReplayGain information in the footer of MP3 files.
WMA (Microsoft) and AAC (Apple) use proprietary file formats.
WAV files can't hold tag information at all."

If reading this hasn't solved the issue after looking into your "Tagger" setting and what revision your tags are, please tell us what type of files you are tagging IE MP3, FLAC, etc. What I am getting at here is that all music files are not tagged alike.

drmatt
2017-11-19, 10:59
God I recently had to write a stack of scripts to strip the id3 tags from my flacs and apply vorbis comments in their place. Apparently grip was always writing id3 even when it was set to output flac. Pain in the butt because the files can't be read by all the tools unless you strip them, and if you strip them you have no titles...


Transcoded from Matt's brain by Tapatalk

ftlight
2017-11-19, 12:48
What types an version of Tag is this mp3tag using?
I followed an advice to only write id3v2 tags and remove all others.
Somewhat unintuitively, it's easy to do this in MP3tag.
In Tools->Options->Tags->Mpeg, check that in Remove all tag types are checked, and in Write just ID3v2 is checked.
Load the files you want to fix, select all, click the big red X on the toolbar. This will remove all tags.
Finally, click the Undo Remove button; this will write back only the ID3v2 tags.

Bill

amey01
2017-11-19, 22:04
Somewhat unintuitively, it's easy to do this in MP3tag.
In Tools->Options->Tags->Mpeg, check that in Remove all tag types are checked, and in Write just ID3v2 is checked.
Load the files you want to fix, select all, click the big red X on the toolbar. This will remove all tags.
Finally, click the Undo Remove button; this will write back only the ID3v2 tags.

Bill

Problem fixed. Thanks all :)