PDA

View Full Version : Tagging for live concerts



usc95
2017-05-12, 16:13
I was curious how most people are going about tagging their concert collections. I have been tagging my shows this way:

Artist: U2
Album: Live at XXX on XX-XX-XXXX
Title: Name of song
Track: 1-20 or 1-1-10 and 2-1-10 depending on if the show is broken up into two discs
Artwork: Embedded in each track

I lament that I haven't hit upon a way to incorporate the quality and source (AUD, SBD etc.) of the recording in these tags and was curious how others are doing it. So how are you tagging your shows?

dasmueller
2017-05-12, 18:07
I put that info in the album field.

Such as- Album: Live at XXX on XX-XX-XXXX SBD

bakker_be
2017-05-15, 04:45
I add it to the Album Field as well, but only if it isn't SBD.
yyyy-mm-dd, venue, city, [state, ]country[ - Origin]

garym
2017-05-15, 13:47
same as bakker_be

Album Name: Year - Month - Day - Venue - City, State [AUD] (if no [AUD], I assume SBD or matrix)

eg., 1977-05-08 - Barton Hall - Ithaca, NY
If I have an official release of something, it might be:
1977-05-08 - Barton Hall - Ithaca, NY - GSTL Box Set
(GSTL is short for "Get Shown the Light")

In comment tag, I might add additional info if particularly pertinent (to me).

Artist: name of artist
Genre: Live Concert
Title: name of song
Tracks 1 - N (I don't bother with keeping things organized in multiple disks, etc. I simplly renumber tracks from 01-N from beginning to end. And I apply ReplayGain values to entire concert as "one album")
artwork: cover.jpg in album folder

EDIT: none of the above applies to commercially released albums (e.g., Allman Brothers Band, Live at the Fillmore East or Humble Pie, Rockin' the Fillmore, or Hot Tuna's first album, or John Mayall, Turning Point, etc.). That said, for things that are part of a "official release of unofficial recordings, I still use the "year - month - day - venue, city, state" approach. As for example with the Grateful Dead Barton Hall recent release noted above, or a "Dick's Picks' series release. I tag these more like unofficial live shows than like original release albums.

bakker_be
2017-05-16, 03:22
One thing I truly dislike about nearly all sources of ROIO's is the seeming insistence on lousy tagging. DxTxx.flac, very nice as a file name, no info in the tags, only an accompanying text file. Lots of manual work to set everything right ;)

garym
2017-05-16, 04:41
One thing I truly dislike about nearly all sources of ROIO's is the seeming insistence on lousy tagging. DxTxx.flac, very nice as a file name, no info in the tags, only an accompanying text file. Lots of manual work to set everything right ;)

agree. There's a component in foobar2000 called "live show tagger" which works quite well (most of the time, particularly on downloads from live music archive at archive.org). If a show has a text file that shows listing of track names, etc., this tagger will parse that text file and automatically add the track names (and venue and other things) to the metadata. I often use this as a first step before cleaning up metadata to suit me.

dasmueller
2017-05-16, 06:41
I'll have to try that out.

I really do not mind the work of tagging ROIOs as it ensures a level of consistency.

bakker_be
2017-05-16, 09:46
agree. There's a component in foobar2000 called "live show tagger" which works quite well (most of the time, particularly on downloads from live music archive at archive.org). If a show has a text file that shows listing of track names, etc., this tagger will parse that text file and automatically add the track names (and venue and other things) to the metadata. I often use this as a first step before cleaning up metadata to suit me.

That's a real good tip. Thanks!

usc95
2017-05-16, 11:27
Thanks guys for the feedback. Adding the source of the show to the title is an obvious thing to do, to bad I didn't consider it until now. I too wish that when folks would upload shows they would at least tag the files with the artist, date and song names but that is a small price to pay I suppose. It still beats shelling out big bucks for poorly produced "bootlegs" like we had to do in the old days though.